Vegan Toad in the Hole

Published: Apr 9, 2018 by Jess & Dan · Modified: Jun 28, 2020 · This post may contain affiliate links

Perhaps the weirdest sounding British dish, but a much loved one and, as it turns out, very easy to veganise! Here’s our delicious vegan toad in the hole recipe…

There’s something extremely comforting about sausages cooked with batter and swimming in gravy. It’s a feel-good meal that is perfect for those wintery nights in or just getting cosy at home.

A baking pan filled with vegan toad in the hole. 4 sausages are visible and the edges of the batter are golden brown. In the background is a jug of gravy and a side dish of broccoli and cauliflower. — Serve vegan toad in the hole with a side of vegetables and a good glug of gravy!

How to make vegan toad in the hole

Toad in the hole is a little more forgiving than our vegan Yorkshire puddings. Cooking the batter in such a large dish, it’s not going to be able to achieve the same rise at the edges or a pronounced dip in the middle. Getting the ratios of your batter mix right is still important though. We made a video tutorial to help:

A lot of the method is shared with our vegan Yorkshire pudding recipe. After all, vegan toad in the hole is just a giant Yorkshire pudding with sausages in it. The main things to remember are:

Have a nice hot oven – pre-heat it and start at gas mark 7 / 200c / 425f.
Pre-heating the oil – it’s important to get the batter cooking as soon as possible. The oil should be smoking hot.
Rest your batter – 15 minutes will do. It’s also important that it’s room temperature, not cold.
Use a metal or ceramic baking dish – they'll get the hottest. You can make 1 large toad in the hole, 2 medium ones or even 4 individual ones.
Work carefully and quickly – you need to get the sausages and batter into the oil, and the dish back in the oven very quickly. The oil needs to stay hot so the batter can start cooking straight away.
Give it a rest – this firms it up. Once done, take out of the oven and leave it to settle for 15-30 minutes. Steaming hot gravy may warm it up, or you can chuck it back in the oven for a few minutes before serving.
If you’re using frozen sausages, defrost or par-cook them before using. The last thing you want after putting all that effort into your batter is for cold sausages to cool it down when it should be cooking!

The ingredients

The batter is similar to a pancake batter and consists of:

Flour – both plain flour and chickpea flour (a.k.a. gram or garbanzo flour). You can also drop the plain flour and double up on the chickpea flour to make gluten free toad in the hole. Chickpea flour is really light and also adds a yellow hue to the batter.
Water – you don’t need to use milk to make a vegan toad in the hole batter, not even a non-dairy milk! You’ll find a lot of Yorkshire pudding and toad in the hole recipes – vegan or otherwise – actually use water as the main liquid.
Baking powder – it acts as a leavening agent to help the batter rise.
Apple cider vinegar – helps to activate the baking powder.
Ground turmeric – adds a golden yellow colour to the batter.
Aquafaba – the miracle ingredient. Typically used as an alternative to egg whites and helps the batter to rise.

Is toad in the hole vegan?

Not traditionally! You’ll typically find eggs and meat-based sausages included, plus some recipes will include milk.

Making a vegan toad in the hole isn’t difficult though, as you’ll find out when you give this recipe a try! Start by replacing the sausages with your favourite plant-based sausages. If they're frozen, make sure to defrost or par-cook them first.

For the batter, it’s as simple as using water instead of milk. Then you can replace the eggs, typically used in a batter like this, with aquafaba. If you’re interested to learn more about how this miracle ingredient works, you can read in detail about aquafaba in our vegan Yorkshire pudding recipe.

Of course, our vegan toad in the hole recipe is completely meat and dairy free. You can very easily make it gluten free by only using chickpea flour too.

A top-down photo of vegan toad in the hole. It's in an enamel dish with a blue rim. Wrapped round the dish is a gingham cloth. The batter is gradients of yellow and golden brown, with 4 sausages poking through the surface.

What is toad in the hole?!

There’s the big question because, let’s face it, “toad in the hole” doesn’t sound particularly appetising! But we promise you, our vegan toad in the hole recipe will leave you satisfied.

This isn’t a very well known dish outside of Britain. I’ve also met a good handful of British people who hadn’t heard of it, so I thought I’d provide a bit of context to the weirdly named dish.

The simple version is this: toad in the hole is sausages in Yorkshire pudding batter (if you’re not sure what Yorkshire puddings are, check out our vegan Yorkshire pudding recipe). It’s a dish that’s typically served up with a side of vegetables and a good glug of gravy.

Onion gravy is the traditional choice, but we’re not precious about that and think it’s equally delicious with some quick and easy Bisto.

We tend to think of it a bit like a quick roast dinner! Whip up a batter, cook it with the sausages, simmer up some vegetables and it’s done.

Originally, cheap meats like sausages, or even leftover cuts of meat were used. It was a cheap and filling meal for workers.

Nobody has been able to establish the origins of the name of the dish. One of the most popular ideas is that it relates to the way that toads hunt their prey, burying themselves in burrows, with just their heads visible.

Either way, there’s no evidence to suggest that this dish was ever made using toads!

A photo of vegan toad in the hole in an enamel dish. A gingham cloth is wrapped round the dish and to the right hand side is a vintage knife and fork. Further back in the photo is an enamel side dish filled with broccoli and cauliflower, on top of a tartan cloth.

What’s the best vegan sausage to use?

Something that’s more like a traditional British banger or Lincolnshire style sausage, in my opinion, are the best to use. But really, use whatever kind of sausage you enjoy – you can get creative and try different flavours and styles out!

The plant-based sausages we love in the UK are:

Linda McCartney – the OG. They recently released a new recipe version of the original sausages and, honestly, they’re really dry. We used to really like them too. The good news is that the newer Lincolnshire style ones are delicious and juicy.
Richmond – incredible vegan sausages. They taste extremely realistic and even have a skin that you can crisp up. Bad news if you’re not into your realistic meat alternatives, but good news if you are.
Sainsbury’s ‘Plant Pioneers’ range – they’re all awesome. My picks for a vegan toad in the hole would be the Cumberland or caramelised onion shroomdogs.

We tried Beyond sausages recently and they were below average at best. They're so expensive that we didn't try them for a long time and I wouldn’t buy them again if they were half the price. Sorry Beyond! I still like your burgers though.

Did you make this recipe? Leave a review and a rating below, or tag us in your photos on Instagram! Alternatively, bookmark it in your browser or save to Pinterest for later.

If you love our content, please consider supporting it by buying us a coffee.

📖 Recipe

If you love this recipe, pin it on Pinterest!

A Pinterest image showing a photo of vegan toad in the hole with the words 'Vegan Toad in the Hole from Store Cupboard Ingredients' written above it.

More Vegan British Recipes

Comments